Durham Schools Honor Educators, Debate Right-Sizing Study

The Durham Public Schools Board of Education celebrates standout students, staff, and school leaders, outlines a stronger financial footing, and then wrestles with a costly right-sizing consultant contract as community members and the board clash over school closures, equity, and how to prepare for a 2028 bond. 63mins

Was this helpful?

Original Meeting

Thursday, November 19th, 2026
14949.0
#DPSCommunity | DPS Board of Education Monthly Meeting | 11/19/26
Video Notes

#DPSCommunity | DPS Board of Education Monthly Meeting | 11/19/26

Neighborhood news guy for Southpoint Access in Durham.
View full bio
In This Video
  • Principal Brandon Hodges from the Southern School of Energy & Sustainability, honored student Danine Omer, highlighting their journey as a recent immigrant overcoming academic obstacles to excel in advanced coursework and rise to the top of the graduating class.
  • Mina Ford introduced eighth grade science teacher Julia Champion as the November Teacher of the Month, highlighting how they consistently went above and beyond to support instruction, colleagues, and the entire Lucas Montessori school community.
  • Mina Ford recognized Miss Karen R. Jones as the November Employee of the Month for leading the implementation of the Meal Plus inventory and ordering program, dedicating extensive time beyond regular duties and exemplifying ownership, perseverance, and departmental leadership.
  • A speaker honored Dr. Tawauna Stewart as Durham Public Schools Principal of the Year, highlighting a trust-centered leadership style that fostered a high-performing, supportive school community at Rogers-Herr Middle School.
  • Superintendent Dr. Anthony Lewis outlined how the district strengthened its financial position by catching up audits, modernizing financial systems, rebuilding reserves, and raising minimum wages and classified staff pay, while emphasizing ongoing challenges and a commitment to transparent, student-centered budgeting.
  • Superintendent Dr. Anthony Lewis introduced a recommendation for a comprehensive right-sizing study to proactively align school facilities and resources with enrollment and strategic priorities, explaining how it aligned with the district’s strategic plan and Board Policy 9000 on long-range facility planning.
  • Superintendent Lewis acknowledged declining enrollment, underutilized facilities, rising operational costs, and uncertain future revenues, emphasizing the district’s responsibility to use taxpayer dollars as effectively as possible to support teaching and learning.
  • Superintendent Lewis clarified that approving the $474,000 right-sizing study was not a decision to close schools but a necessary investment to gather comprehensive data on enrollment, facilities, equity, and finances so future resource decisions would better support scholars and communities.
  • Superintendent Lewis addressed community concerns about the right-sizing consultant, emphasizing that the firm would provide objective data and analysis while final decisions about Durham Public Schools’ future would remain with the Board, administration, and community.
  • A speaker, identifying as a parent and public school advocate, criticized opposition to the right-sizing study as protecting privileged access to certain schools and urged the Board to approve the study as an opportunity for more equitable and creative solutions.
  • A DPS student urged the Board to prioritize smaller, community-centered schools, maintain existing buildings, and make public schools more attractive to families rather than consolidating into large hubs.
  • A speaker discussing consolidation on behalf of anonymous parents, urged the Board to reject the proposed consulting contract for school consolidation, invest instead in improving student nutrition, and ensure families have a meaningful voice before any decisions that could disrupt neighborhood schools are made.
  • A DPS parent and child well-being researcher urged the Board not to approve the MGT consulting contract, arguing that the district had not clearly defined the problems it sought to solve and should first review forthcoming Growing Together study data before committing hundreds of thousands of dollars to a new process.
  • Mika Hunter Twietmeyer, president of the Durham Association of Educators, opposed the MGT right-sizing and consolidation contract by citing contentious school closure experiences in other districts and urging the Board to rely on existing community engagement structures instead of taking any steps toward closing schools.
  • Several speakers, including parent organizers and advocates, ceded time to a speaker who presented a petition opposing a right-sizing and consolidation study, warning that school closures disproportionately harmed marginalized students and urging the Board to pursue neighborhood-based enrollment recovery and equitable outcomes in partnership with communities.
  • A speaker, drawing on work with a facility management system used in Guilford County Schools, recounted how a consulting firm that claimed database expertise actually produced unusable, messy data, raising doubts about the reliability of such contractors.
  • Chair Harrell Goff concluded public comment, led the Board in unanimously approving the consent items, and then moved the meeting to an Academic Services presentation on advanced academics.
  • Devan Mitchell explained that the right-sizing study was designed with transparency, engagement, and Board guardrails, and that its recommendations would be integrated with existing facility condition data into a 10-year capital improvement plan aimed at an academically, fiscally, and physically healthy district.
  • Ms. Mitchell explained that, following a capital improvement task force’s finding that roughly 36.5% of district facilities—about 20 schools—were in significantly poor or critical condition, the Board approved a right-sizing and consolidation study in June 2026 to help prioritize major tear-downs and modernizations beyond physical health alone.
  • Ms. Mitchell highlighted stark differences in family experiences across schools due to uneven facilities and resources, and underscored that infrequent, limited funding cycles made careful prioritization of the district’s many unmet needs essential.
  • Ms. Mitchell explained that the retooled right-sizing study extended the consultant’s timeline to 12 months without increasing fees, compressing the subsequent capital improvement planning work and making prompt contract approval essential for the district’s team to meet tight deadlines for cost estimates and phasing plans.
  • Ms. Mitchell outlined the four-phase right-sizing process, emphasizing that the Board would review and approve each phase and that early, upfront engagement would establish guiding principles in month one and revisit them in month four using baseline data to refine the project’s core values.
  • Board Member Wendell Tabb reflected on the closure and repurposing of Holton Middle School to highlight the value of community engagement, stressed that no school closures or consolidations had been proposed, and urged the Board not to delay decisions that affected students in aging facilities.
  • Vice Chair Xavier Cason reflected on prior community-wide task force work, expressed regret that robust engagement around right-sizing had not occurred earlier, and stated discomfort with approving even a phased consultant contract due to missed opportunities.
  • Board Member Wendell Tabb opposed the high-cost right-sizing contract and current vendor, instead supporting robust community engagement, recommending approval of only the lower-cost first phase and issuing a new RFP for later phases based on community-suggested alternatives.
  • Chair Joy Harrell Goff acknowledged Board Member Tabb’s concerns, emphasized the importance of existing studies and community engagement, and stated a lack of confidence in moving forward with the right-sizing consultant contract due to how the engagement process had unfolded and eroded community trust.
  • Board Member Bent Kitaif and Board Member Rivero agreed on the need for demographic and geographic data but questioned the high-cost consultant, suggesting less expensive alternatives and emphasizing that any firm selected must be perceived by the community as presenting data from an unbiased background.
  • Board Member Millicent Rogers acknowledged colleagues’ concerns about bias with the MGT consultant, questioned why the RFP issues were only being confronted so late, and urged the Board to give clear guidance so future RFPs attract unbiased firms and avoid repeating the same situation.
  • Chair Harrell Goff invited a motion on the right-sizing consultant contract, and Board Member Wendell Tabb proposed hiring the contractor only for phase one with a new RFP for later phases, but the motion failed for lack of a second after Tabb cautioned against micromanaging administration and urged action to address students’ needs in aging facilities.
  • Chair Harrell Goff called for a decision on the right-sizing consultant contract, and after an unidentified Board member moved—seconded by Board Member Rivero—to direct administration not to take any action with the MGT contract, the Board approved the motion in a 5–2 vote.
  • Board Member Gabby Rivero moved, with a friendly amendment from Board Member Tabb and support from Chair Harrell Goff, to direct administration to develop a comprehensive capital needs status report and bond proposal for Durham County that included 10-year enrollment projections, facility condition and utilization analyses, and a needs assessment for under-enrolled schools, while keeping costs at or below the previously proposed consultant contract.
  • In response to questions about implementation, Board Member Rivero outlined options for carrying out the new capital needs motion, including issuing a fresh RFP, creating an RFQ to build a pool of data providers, or assigning the work to the district’s facilities department.
  • Board Member Rogers questioned how administration would be equipped to advocate for a future bond under the new capital needs approach, stressing that commissioners required both data and analysis and asking who would synthesize information from multiple vendors, on what timeline, and whether the Board or administration should lead that work.
  • Chair Harrell Goff explained that the Board had overturned the administration’s recommendation to use MGT and was now directing administration to partner with the Board on developing alternative ways to obtain key data needed for a 2028 bond request.
  • Ms. Mitchell used an example of investing bond funds in an under-enrolled school to explain why a comprehensive right-sizing study—examining enrollment, boundaries, and facilities together—was needed to avoid piecemeal decisions and ensure resources were spent wisely.
  • Board Member Natalie Bent Kitaif urged the Board to design any future RFP with longer timelines and clear guardrails so that local universities and values-aligned, including women- and minority-owned, organizations could fairly compete for the work.
  • Board Member Wendell Tabb proposed taking the right-sizing and data work back to the Facilities Committee to confer with administration, while Dr. Deborah Pittman outlined a grant-funded Growing Together research partnership with Duke University and Vice Chair Xavier Cason supported using that study and committee input to shape a future RFP.
  • Board members stressed the need for clear, timely direction to administration on data and bond preparation, urging better advance communication about studies like the Duke partnership while Board Member Tabb cautioned about tight timelines, the limited number of upcoming meetings, and the possibility of restarting the RFP process through the Facilities Committee.
  • Chair Harrell Goff emphasized aligning the future bond proposal with county-identified requirements, advocated for more regular school bonds beyond 2028, and outlined interest in the Superintendent developing an equity-centered community engagement strategy to guide long-term facilities planning and any potential school closures or consolidations.
  • Board Member Bent Kitaif proposed reframing the capital needs motion as a 2028 bond proposal draft without predetermined consolidation decisions, emphasized the necessity of robust community engagement to protect public trust, while another speaker noted legal requirements for hearings before school closures and the need to honestly address enrollment projections for future bond approvals.
  • Vice Chair Xavier Cason and Board Member Gabby Rivero discussed procedurally voting down the existing motion and then immediately introducing a new one, aiming to move Ms. Mitchell’s feedback to the Facilities Committee and keep the right-sizing conversation moving forward.
  • Board Member Nadeen Bir cautioned against voting down Rivero’s motion, arguing that its initial items could be handled in-house without a consultant, that existing staff work and demography efforts should be better coordinated, and that the community was not ready for a right-sizing or consolidation study even as the district pursued a bond to improve school facilities.
  • Board Member Millicent Rogers warned that the district was approaching a fiscal cliff, urged Board Member Bir to convene community voices for courageous, evidence-based decision-making, and explained voting against the motion because its three outlined items were too narrow for the district’s needs.
  • After a motion failed 2–5, Chair Harrell Goff sought consensus to send the issue to the Facilities Committee, while a speaker stressed that any new RFP would require clearer Board guardrails on price, community engagement expectations, timeline, and recognition that applicant firms and their philosophies were largely beyond administrative control.
  • Superintendent Lewis reflected on Durham’s history of delaying tough decisions, urged the Board to change that narrative, highlighted recent academic gains as evidence the district could become premier, and drew on prior work about fiscal cliffs to encourage leaders to trust administration’s experience in making hard, community-informed resource decisions.
  • Chair Harrell Goff responded to Superintendent Lewis’s comments by affirming confidence in administration’s ability to lead robust community engagement without the MGT consultant while still meeting the timeline for the upcoming bond.
Your Governments
Your governments list is empty.